1. New Story with Another Abductor or Supernatural Threat: The sequel could introduce a new antagonist with similar psychological terror elements, but with different powers or methods. The black phone might be tied to something deeper—perhaps a cursed object connected to a dark supernatural force. A new child or group of children could be abducted by a different type of predator, allowing the ghosts to offer help in escaping or providing insight into the malevolent powers behind the black phone.
2. Gwen’s Psychic Abilities Explored Further: In the first film, Gwen’s psychic dreams were integral to the plot. In the sequel, her abilities could be expanded and explored more deeply, leading her to confront a darker and more powerful supernatural threat. This could create a more intense horror dynamic, as Gwen tries to prevent future kidnappings or encounters more dangerous entities than before.
3. Prequel Explaining The Grabber’s Backstory: Another possible direction for The Black Phone 2 could be a prequel, delving into the origins of The Grabber and how the black phone came to be linked to the spirits of his victims. This could explore The Grabber’s past and show his early crimes, shedding light on the supernatural aspects of the phone and why it connects to the afterlife. The film could follow his earlier victims, expanding on their stories and how they ended up trapped in the spirit world.
4. The Black Phone’s True Purpose: The phone itself could become the focus of the sequel, with an exploration of its origins. The film might reveal that the black phone is an ancient, cursed object that allows contact with the dead and is tied to a much larger paranormal mystery. The device could have a history that spans beyond The Grabber, connecting other kidnappings or unsolved cases, leading Finney or Gwen to investigate the phone’s true purpose or to destroy it before it claims more victims.
5. Haunted Urban Legend: A sequel could take a different approach, making the black phone an urban legend, where teenagers or thrill-seekers attempt to use the phone to contact the spirits of the dead, only to unleash a malevolent force. The story could shift to a larger scope, with multiple characters being affected by the phone and dealing with terrifying consequences when they inadvertently summon evil spirits.
6. Finney as a Protector: A possible follow-up story could see Finney growing older and becoming a protector figure for other children or teens who fall prey to similar supernatural threats. Having survived The Grabber, he might now possess knowledge of the black phone and use it to help others avoid a similar fate. This direction could explore his trauma and resilience, as well as his continued connection to the spirits.

Returning Characters

• Finney Shaw (Mason Thames): If the sequel continues Finney’s story, we might see him older and more experienced, possibly dealing with the lingering psychological effects of his encounter with The Grabber. His connection to the black phone could still exist, allowing him to communicate with spirits and help others.
• Gwen Shaw (Madeleine McGraw): Gwen’s psychic abilities could evolve in the sequel, giving her a more central role in confronting supernatural forces. She might use her powers to hunt down other abductors or find herself entangled with darker spirits connected to the black phone.
• Ghosts of Previous Victims: The spirits of The Grabber’s victims were crucial to the first film, and a sequel could introduce new spirits, each with their own backstories and connections to the black phone. They could offer new insights into the supernatural realm and the terror tied to the device.

Tone and Atmosphere

If The Black Phone 2 maintains the dark and intense atmosphere of the first film, we can expect a blend of supernatural horror with psychological tension. The eerie, confined setting of the basement could be replaced with new, equally unsettling locations, such as abandoned buildings, haunted locations, or other isolated environments where the phone might resurface. The film would likely continue its exploration of themes like childhood trauma, fear, and survival in the face of evil.

Conclusion

While details for The Black Phone 2 (2025) are still unknown, the potential for the sequel is vast, offering opportunities to expand on the supernatural elements, character backstories, and the eerie power of the black phone itself. Whether it’s a continuation of Finney and Gwen’s story or a completely new tale connected to the cursed phone, the film could deliver another tense, atmospheric horror experience with plenty of psychological twists and paranormal terror.